• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Seventh Row

A place to think deeply about movies

  • Articles
  • eBooks
  • Podcasts
    • Seventh Row Podcast
    • The Joachim Trier Audio Commentaries
    • 21st Folio
    • Seventh Row on other podcasts
  • Women at Cannes
  • Merch
  • Log in
  • Join now!
Home / Essays / TIFF19 review: Hind Meddeb’s documentary Paris Stalingrad captures a particular political moment

B. P. Flanagan / September 9, 2019

TIFF19 review: Hind Meddeb’s documentary Paris Stalingrad captures a particular political moment

Hind Meddeb’s Paris Stalingrad questions the spectacle of authoritarian xenophobia.

A scene from the Paris’ refugee centre, Stalingrad in Hind Meddeb's documentary
Still from Paris Stalingrad. Courtesy of TIFF

Establishing shots evoking News From Home locate us in Paris’ refugee centre, Stalingrad, where newcomers to the city, who sleep in tents in the street, spend their days queueing for asylum meetings. Riot police suited in thick, inhuman armour, clash with refugees who have little more to protect them than a coat and backpack. 

The act of documenting this brings up key moral questions: the anonymity of the people is necessary for legal reasons, but I felt a troubling disengagement in the impact of Director Hind Meddeb’s cool, Laura Poitras-style voice-over, which at times seems dispassionate towards these people’s lack of agency and their wider situation. Her actions on screen are empathetic and perceptive, which makes her persona difficult to grapple with. For a POV documentary, sometimes it’s hard to know what she’s thinking. 

This rough piece of street reportage uses the camera with directness, it’s presence on the scene questioning the spectacle of authoritarian xenophobia. The mobility of the camera makes this more than a TV news feature. Meddeb captures a chorus of voices expressing anxiety, friendship, history. Paris Stalingrad’s purpose seems not to presume to change things with her filmmaking as much as to capture the stories that took place within this period. In that unswerving, ungarnished journalism perhaps the more political act can be found. 

Still seeking distribution in the US, UK, and Canada

Screens 9/10 at 7:15 p.m. (Scotiabank Theatre); 9/12 at 6:00 p.m. (Scotiabank Theatre); and 9/14 at 9:30 a.m. (Scotiabank Theatre) . Tickets here.

Discover more of the best acquisition titles at TIFF19 >>

Tweet
Share65
Share
65 Shares

Filed Under: Directed by Women, Documentary, Essays, Film Reviews, Social Justice Tagged With: Documentary, Women Directors

B. P. Flanagan

B.P. Flanagan is a film and culture critic based in London.

« Older Post
TIFF19 review: Kuessipan , a standout Indigenous coming-of-age story
Newer Post »
TIFF19 review: The Body Remembers When the World Broke Open uses real-time duration for poignant effect

Footer






Seventh Row

  • Log In
  • Film Adventurer Membership
  • Merchandise
  • Cinephile Membership
  • Institutional Subscriptions
  • Donate
  • Shop
  • Start here
  • About
  • Contact Us

Our Ebooks

  • Existential detours: Joachim Trier’s cinema of indecisions and revisions
  • Subjectives realities: The art of creative nonfiction film – an ebook
  • In their own words: Fiction directors – an ebook on filmmaking
  • Roads to nowhere: Kelly Reichardt’s broken American dreams – an ebook to prepare you for First Cow
  • Portraits of Resistance: The Cinema of Céline Sciamma
  • Beyond Empowertainment: Feminist Horror and The Struggle for Female Agency
  • The 2019 Canadian Cinema Yearbook
  • Tour of Memories: on Joanna Hogg’s The Souvenir
  • Peterloo in Process: A Mike Leigh collaboration
  • In their own words: Documentary masters vol. 1
  • Leave No Trace
  • Lean on Pete
  • You Were Never Really Here
  • Call Me by Your Name

Browse

  • Start here
  • Directors We Love
  • Films We Love
  • Guide to Canadian film
  • World Cinema for Young Adults
  • Family Viewing Guide
  • Interview Index by Job Title
  • Interview Index by Last Name

Directors We Love

  • Andrew Haigh
  • Joanna Hogg
  • Mike Leigh
  • Kelly Reichardt
  • Céline Sciamma
  • Joachim Trier
  • Alice Winocour

Discover Great Films: Take a Challenge

  • Kelly Reichardt Challenge
  • Céline Sciamma challenge
  • Joanna Hogg Challenge
  • Canadian Cinema Challenge





Connect with us

  • Workshops and Lockdown Film School
  • Events
  • Podcast
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

Follow Us on Social Media

  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube

© 2022 · Seventh Row

  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • FAQ
  • Contribute
  • Contact